• We are now running on a new, and hopefully much-improved, server. In addition we are also on new forum software. Any move entails a lot of technical details and I suspect we will encounter a few issues as the new server goes live. Please be patient with us. It will be worth it! :) Please help by posting all issues here.
  • The forum will be down for about an hour this weekend for maintenance. I apologize for the inconvenience.
  • If you are having trouble seeing the forum then you may need to clear your browser's DNS cache. Click here for instructions on how to do that
  • Please review the Forum Rules frequently as we are constantly trying to improve the forum for our members and visitors.

Pretend your a "robber" (oc) vs (cc)

newbie

Regular Member
Joined
Apr 26, 2012
Messages
148
Location
west bend
Ok just for the sake of argument between me and my buddy....... say your a harden criminal and today is the day your going to rob some guy walking down the road. Now guy #1 has a open carried firearm in plane sight. And guy #2 also is packing heat but his is hiden from your view so hes cc. Now today obviously is not your day. Both guys packing a firearm. Who are you going to attack guy #1 or guy #2 reply with thoughts please


if it was me id say im going for the guy whos not oc because it seems to be the easier bet

My friend who is a ccw holder says if he was to do it he would go for the guy whos oc because its a easy grab for a firearm.
 

Fallschirjmäger

Active member
Joined
Aug 4, 2007
Messages
3,823
Location
Cumming, Georgia, USA
Probably less than 3% of the population carries a firearm regularly (and that is a SWAG)

Given that, is there an advantage to looking like one of the 97% who are helpless, or is there an advantage to looking like you may be a problem?

It works the same as having visible bars on the windows, a "Guarded by XXX Company" sign in the yard, a dog food bowl with "Killer" left on the front porch and a host of other things. If you can make it look difficult, most robbers will pick an easier target - same reward, less work. That's just smart thug-thinking.


Why do officers wear easily identifiable uniforms? Drive distinctively marked patrol cars?
Wouldn't it be ~more effective~ to deterring crime if you couldn't tell if the guy next to you was a cop on patrol or just another guy walking on the sidewalk? You'd be worried that every casually dressed male that wasn't wearing a wife-beater was packing a badge.
 

09jisaac

Regular Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2011
Messages
1,692
Location
Louisa, Kentucky
Naturally I would go for the guy not carrying a gun (I don't know he is).

If I knew both were packing heat I would, still, target the CCer. An OCer can ALWAYS pull faster than a CCer with similar gear and training. I am not saying that some CCers can't beat an OCer, but that is the exception.
 

newbie

Regular Member
Joined
Apr 26, 2012
Messages
148
Location
west bend
Naturally I would go for the guy not carrying a gun (I don't know he is).

If I knew both were packing heat I would, still, target the CCer. An OCer can ALWAYS pull faster than a CCer with similar gear and training. I am not saying that some CCers can't beat an OCer, but that is the exception.

I made that a point of my argument that I can draw my gun alot faster with my oc holster then I could with my in the waistband holster.

With all of these points im trying to prove to him he still says that a robber will target me before him but the only difrence is that in each of his arguments os that the robber will come behind me and they will attack him from the front only.. I sware some people are so hard headed
 

Gil223

Regular Member
Joined
Jan 5, 2012
Messages
1,392
Location
Weber County Utah
I made that a point of my argument that I can draw my gun alot faster with my oc holster then I could with my in the waistband holster.

With all of these points im trying to prove to him he still says that a robber will target me before him but the only difrence is that in each of his arguments os that the robber will come behind me and they will attack him from the front only.. I sware some people are so hard headed

You didn't say if the "robber" was armed or not, but I'm assuming he isn't since he has to approach you from behind. Other than the fact that an unarmed robber would be foolish to attack an obviously armed citizen (who I'll also assume knows something about weapon retention), there's also the possibility - remote that it may be - that your hardened criminal has "gunfighter's syndrome", and knows that (statistically) he can act before you can react, therefore sees the armed citizen as a challenge. :uhoh: The average person who must react is almost always a split second behind the one who initiates action against him... unless your name is Bob Munden (see below vid). Pax...
[video=youtube;XsU5AMxvlKg]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XsU5AMxvlKg[/video]
P.S. The audio is in English
 
Last edited:

since9

Campaign Veteran
Joined
Jan 14, 2010
Messages
6,964
Location
Colorado Springs, Colorado, USA
Ok just for the sake of argument between me and my buddy....... say your a harden criminal and today is the day your going to rob some guy walking down the road. Now guy #1 has a open carried firearm in plane sight. And guy #2 also is packing heat but his is hiden from your view so hes cc. Now today obviously is not your day. Both guys packing a firearm. Who are you going to attack guy #1 or guy #2 reply with thoughts please.

If I were that hardened and my only choice was to rob either of these two, I'd dispatch guy #2 before he knew what hit him, assuming he was armed anyway, regardless of whether I was able to spot it or not. Reason: It takes between a split second and a couple of seconds longer to draw and fire from concealed than it does from open carry.

If I were really that hardened and had a choice, however, I'd become a lawyer and pray on the emotional turbidity of divorce and child custody. That's where the money is. My divorce attorney's bookcase held pictures of his mansion, pool, boat, motorhome, and second house on the lake. Obviously, not the brightest of attorneys, yet he wasn't hurting.

My heart, however, is nowhere near that hard! Having been through that grief, I have way too much compassion to ever do that. I could see myself becoming a defense attorney, but not if I had to first be a public prosecutor.

My friend who is a ccw holder says if he was to do it he would go for the guy whos oc because its a easy grab for a firearm.

You're friend is sadly mistaken, and I hope he never tries it, as he's likely to wind up dead. Grabbing a firearm out of a retention holster is NOT an "easy grab." The basic retention technique of secure, spin, and block is fairly easy to learn, and quite effective when done properly. It's a matter of leverage, not strength. It also opens the gun grabber up to two in the chest, one in the head, which would effectively put a sad but permanent end to your friend's mistaken ideas.

The other thing about which your friend is mistaken is that a robber will "take out the opposition." I am no Bob Munden, but I can draw, fire, and hit a man standing twenty feet away in less than a second, and criminals know this. They also know they cannot approach without drawing the attention of an alert OCer. Stay alert, use your hearing, move your vision at least 45 degrees left and right of facing forward so you're checking six with peripheral vision, and be observant of the behavior of others, and nine times out of ten, your potential attacker will have aborted you as a target simply because you're OCing. Of the remaining 10% who might have been sizing you up anyway, they'll abort 90% of the time because you're being alert. So, between OC and being alert, you're about 1% as likely to be attacked as the average citizen.*

*Yes, the stats are fictitious, but we really don't have very good stats on this, anyway, other than if you're OCing you're several times more likely to be harassed, and illegally so, by law enforcement. I do know that criminals don't walk around taking pot-shots at OCers, because if they miss, they're in for a world of hurt.

This video's resolution isn't the best, but consider the difference between the predator (wolf/criminal), the prey (sheep/most people), and the sheepdog (sheep dog/me). Observe who's standing triumphantly over the wolf at 3:58 into the video.

[video=youtube;YssyfRaTli8]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YssyfRaTli8[/video]
 
Last edited:

Steeler-gal

Regular Member
Joined
Oct 29, 2011
Messages
560
Location
Fairfax County, VA
Ok just for the sake of argument between me and my buddy....... say your a harden criminal and today is the day your going to rob some guy walking down the road. Now guy #1 has a open carried firearm in plane sight. And guy #2 also is packing heat but his is hiden from your view so hes cc. Now today obviously is not your day. Both guys packing a firearm. Who are you going to attack guy #1 or guy #2 reply with thoughts please


if it was me id say im going for the guy whos not oc because it seems to be the easier bet

My friend who is a ccw holder says if he was to do it he would go for the guy whos oc because its a easy grab for a firearm.

IMO anyone who attacks someone who is obviously armed is not a hardened criminal, they are stupid. Assuming you can grab a gun out of a holster without detection or without a fight is just dumb.


==========================================
NRA Certified Range Safety Officer
Looking for training by experienced staff?
We are the largest all female only firearms group on the East Coast offering firearms training courses and services provided by our experienced and certified female instructors.
http://www.shecanshoot.com/
 

Gil223

Regular Member
Joined
Jan 5, 2012
Messages
1,392
Location
Weber County Utah
Observe who's standing triumphantly over the wolf at 3:58 into the video.

You make some excellent points, however... had the sheepdogs and the shepherd been doing their jobs at the outset there would be no dead sheep. Which is exactly why the world needs more alert sheepdogs among the multitudes of sheeples. ;) Pax...
 

newbie

Regular Member
Joined
Apr 26, 2012
Messages
148
Location
west bend
I had my friend read threw some of these and the 40 comments on facebook stating he was wrong, but he still says he wins this argument. Not sure if hes that hard headed or droped on his head... Thanks for all the replys, there was some real good points in here

Also in my argument I added that my holster sits directly above my right front pocket. Its the best spot for me. So I cant picture anyone grabing me from behind and not getting shot in the mix of it all.
 

OC for ME

Regular Member
Joined
Jan 6, 2010
Messages
12,452
Location
White Oak Plantation
,snip> They also know they cannot approach without drawing the attention of an alert OCer. Stay alert, use your hearing, move your vision at least 45 degrees left and right of facing forward so you're checking six with peripheral vision, and be observant of the behavior of others, <snip>
Then the sun goes down....
 

Gil223

Regular Member
Joined
Jan 5, 2012
Messages
1,392
Location
Weber County Utah
I had my friend read threw some of these and the 40 comments on facebook stating he was wrong, but he still says he wins this argument.

It sounds as if your friend has some issues regarding his inability to admit that he could possibly be wrong about anything. It's a fairly common problem though, and one which he shares with several people in this forum. ;) Pax...
 

scott58dh

Regular Member
Joined
Oct 16, 2011
Messages
425
Location
why?
Man Legally Carrying Gun Robbed at Gunpoint

Check it Out !!! :shocker:

:eek: MILWAUKEE, WI.

:arrow: ; http://www.todaystmj4.com/news/local/95999354.html

"The 34-year-old man legally owned a handgun and carried it out in the open in his holster for protection.

"It was kind of scary to just see him walking around all the time with that gun kind of just out in the open,"

But it wasn't scary for at least one person who robbed "The guy with the gun" at gunpoint."

So, to answer you directly, I'd WHACK the OC'er 1st ( jump Him/Her from cover wit' a tire iron in da' back o' da' head) then lay inta da' udder one like a bad habbit then ske-daddle outta there !!!

Dat's whut AH'd doooo !!!:lol:

:cool: PEACE & RKBA FOREVER !!!
 

newbie

Regular Member
Joined
Apr 26, 2012
Messages
148
Location
west bend
Thats the story my friend was talking about. I wasnt sure it was real or some bs. but now I see that it was a real story I just cant picture it happening. Theres some really dumb guys out there but come on now. Thats asking to die if you make one small slip in that robbery, also im not sure if iv read this right but its going to make this man not carry, or just not oc? I wiah I could be in his shoes that day. Not to be robbed but the chance to ask the robber WTF ARE YOU THINKING!?! That guy must not care for life itself or is off his meds.


Also you are vary right he is the only hes right, type of guy weather we are talking about our motorcycles,guns,cars

I remember one day we were fighting avout whos bike was faster threw the turns his hayabusa or my ninja 650r we lined them up on a dead country road and off we went I raced threw them pushing my bike as hard as I could threw turn 1 and 2 I look behind myself not seeing him so I went to panic mode. Exspect the worse type of thing I ride back dont see him anywhere I park my bike so quick on turn 1s sholder that I almost dumped it I begin running threw the ditchs looking for him or a bike after looking and about 20min I see no sign I give up go home so pissed off about what happened. I call him later that night he told me after we started the race his wofe called he had to turn around. Needless to say I didnt talk to him for about a month. But that kind of gives you an idea, thats how he gets out of crap to keep him thinking hes right
 
Top