imported post
pkbites wrote:
I see auctions on Gunbroker for 9mm revolvers, usually S&W, Rugers, & Taurus, but some foreign models too. The Taurus are quite resonable, $280 or so for brand new ones. They are usually snub nose.
Has anyone here ever shot one? How does the 9mm handle in a revolver? How is felt recoil and muzzle lip? What would you compare it too recoil wise? A .38? How is controlability of the 9mm in a snubby frame? Is it comfortable to shoot? Would you recommend it?
Also, would a .380acp cartridge also fit in the cylinder
Thanks in advance for any replies.
My primary (concealed) carry is a Taurus 905 snub-nose revolver in 9mm. It's wearing smooth wood Excaliber grips for anti-snag and better concealability.
Shooting it is like shooting a hotter .38SPL out of my 2" Ruger SP101--it has significant kick, but it isn't as punishing as .357 Mag out of the SP101. It'd probably be on-par with a .38SPL+P (although I've never shot +P). So recoil-wise, it's between .38SPL and .357Mag, and closer to .38SPL.
After I put 100 rounds through it with the stock grips (and developing a bruise on my thumb-joint), I switched to a set of Pachmayr Compac grips, which did OK but negatively affected the concealablility of the weapon (the grips were too bulky, and being rubber, they tended to grab onto my cover clothing), so I swapped it out for the smooth wood Excaliber boot-grips. Interestingly, when I went to these grips the 905 became even
less uncomfortable to shoot than with the other grips, and by putting my pinky below the grips, my thumb-joint hasn't had a single complaint.
The 9mm rounds will headspace on a little shoulder cut into the chambers, and the revolver will shoot just fine this way, although to eject the rounds I have to use a rod of some sort to poke them out. To be able to use the ejector rod, you'd have to use the star-clips, which is both a plus and a minus--they allow for fast reloads, but putting the rounds in the clips and taking the empties out is somewhat annoying. Keeping a spare, loaded clip will not be easy, and there aren't any speedloaders for 9mm rounds (that I know of).
Because the .380 cases are shorter, I don't think the .380 cartridge will headspace correctly without the star-clip, though I've never tried to use .380 cartridges in it. Maybe it'll work, but I don't really have a reason to try it (unless someone wants to buy me a box of .380 to give it a shot).
Do I recommend it? What can a 9mm snubbie revolver do that a J-frame in .38SPL can't? Being able to share the same ammo between my Taurus 905, my Ruger Blackhawk Convertible .357/9mm, and my Beretta 92FS is nice, and factory ammo is certainly cheaper for 9mm. That, and the novelty of having a revolver in 9mm are its biggest pluses.