• We are now running on a new, and hopefully much-improved, server. In addition we are also on new forum software. Any move entails a lot of technical details and I suspect we will encounter a few issues as the new server goes live. Please be patient with us. It will be worth it! :) Please help by posting all issues here.
  • The forum will be down for about an hour this weekend for maintenance. I apologize for the inconvenience.
  • If you are having trouble seeing the forum then you may need to clear your browser's DNS cache. Click here for instructions on how to do that
  • Please review the Forum Rules frequently as we are constantly trying to improve the forum for our members and visitors.

Asked to leave Carmike Ritz 15

Cadet Higham

Regular Member
Joined
Oct 25, 2007
Messages
71
Location
Salt Lake, , USA
imported post

Onthe 31st, my wife and I went on a double date with a couple of friends and we went out to dinner at Olive Garden and then to a movie at the Carmike Ritz 15. After dinner, my friend's date finally realized that I was carrying and asked the usual questions. She didn't seem to interested, but wasn't objectionable to the idea of normal people carrying firearms.

We talked for a little while and then went to see a movie at the Carmike 12. When we got there, they told us that the movie had already started, but at the 15 across town, there was another showing of the same movie that we would be able to catch. (A little background: I generally avoid going to the Carmike 15 as I used to work there a long time ago, and my brother still works there) But we agreed that was the best course and went to the 15. After purchasing our tickets, I was talking to the General Manager and one of the Security personnel, who didn't say anything about my firearm. After getting into the theater and sitting down, that same security guard walked up to me and we had the following conversation

Security:"Excuse me, are you carrying a piece."

Me:"Yes, sir. I am."

Security:"You can't do that."

Me: "I amfully withinthe law by carrying a firearm openly."

Security: "But this is private property."

Me: "I didn't see any 'No Firearms' signs and neither you or the General Manager previously indicated that this was a problem."

Security: "It's scaring our customers."

Me: "I understand that many people feel skiddish around weapons. I carry for my protection, the protection of my family, and everyone around me, regardless if they're skiddish around guns or not."

Security: "Well we received a complaint from a man and his son who saw you in the bathroom with it."

Me: "I haven't gone into your restrooms tonight."

Security: "But it's against our company policy. Will you leave your weapon in your vehicle."

Me: "It doesn't do anybody any good in the car. If I were to leave it there, would you take responsibility if it was stolen."

Security: "No..."

Me: "I guarantee you that the safest place for this firearm is where it is right now."

Security: "Then I'm going to have to ask you to leave."

Me: "Very well, I will comply. Please expect a formal complaint to be delivered to Carmike Cinemas, as well as a request for a clarification of their policies."



I emailed the Carmike Cinemas corporate office and have spoken with a manager and have received no replies yet.
 

UTOC-45-44

Regular Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2007
Messages
2,579
Location
Morgan, Utah, USA
imported post

Cadet Higham wrote:
Onthe 31st, my wife and I went on a double date with a couple of friends and we went out to dinner at Olive Garden and then to a movie at the Carmike Ritz 15. After dinner, my friend's date finally realized that I was carrying and asked the usual questions. She didn't seem to interested, but wasn't objectionable to the idea of normal people carrying firearms.

We talked for a little while and then went to see a movie at the Carmike 12. When we got there, they told us that the movie had already started, but at the 15 across town, there was another showing of the same movie that we would be able to catch. (A little background: I generally avoid going to the Carmike 15 as I used to work there a long time ago, and my brother still works there) But we agreed that was the best course and went to the 15. After purchasing our tickets, I was talking to the General Manager and one of the Security personnel, who didn't say anything about my firearm. After getting into the theater and sitting down, that same security guard walked up to me and we had the following conversation

Security:"Excuse me, are you carrying a piece."

Me:"Yes, sir. I am."

Security:"You can't do that."

Me: "I amfully withinthe law by carrying a firearm openly."

Security: "But this is private property."

Me: "I didn't see any 'No Firearms' signs and neither you or the General Manager previously indicated that this was a problem."

Security: "It's scaring our customers."

Me: "I understand that many people feel skiddish around weapons. I carry for my protection, the protection of my family, and everyone around me, regardless if they're skiddish around guns or not."

Security: "Well we received a complaint from a man and his son who saw you in the bathroom with it."

Me: "I haven't gone into your restrooms tonight."

Security: "But it's against our company policy. Will you leave your weapon in your vehicle."

Me: "It doesn't do anybody any good in the car. If I were to leave it there, would you take responsibility if it was stolen."

Security: "No..."

Me: "I guarantee you that the safest place for this firearm is where it is right now."

Security: "Then I'm going to have to ask you to leave."

Me: "Very well, I will comply. Please expect a formal complaint to be delivered to Carmike Cinemas, as well as a request for a clarification of their policies."



I emailed the Carmike Cinemas corporate office and have spoken with a manager and have received no replies yet.

Wow. That's sad.

Here comes a "tricky" question though.

If a person DOES NOT have a CFP and goes into a Dark Area such as a Movie Theater. Is the gun "concealed" from the Public due to the fact that they CANNOT see it. The seat covers it from the side.

Just some thoughts. Although I have been told by my wife that it's bad for me to think:lol:



TJ
 

Outsider

Regular Member
Joined
May 22, 2008
Messages
385
Location
Orem, Utah, USA
imported post

TJ, I've asked myself the same question. When I go donate plasma twice a week I think about this because I usually put a coat over me because I get cold and that coat, along with the arm rest, cover my gun. Even without a coat it is covered. So I just leave it in the car. Now as for the movie theater, I don't know. I would "personally" say no, it is still in plain view even with the seat, but that is just me. I haven't done it yet so I don't know.

That is too bad about that theater but good just stating that is was legal carry and staying cool. Keep us updated. By the way, did you get a refund?
 

Axctal

Regular Member
Joined
May 13, 2007
Messages
24
Location
, ,
imported post

"But it's against our company policy"



The proper way to answer that would be

"I am not working for your company, your company policy does not apply to me"

or "Is it in employee handbook? Well, I am not your employee"
 

xmirage2kx

Regular Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2007
Messages
478
Location
Lehi, Utah, USA
imported post

And what if I have a drop thigh holster and turn away from you.... now that you can't see it is it concealed?

If under normal circumstances your gun is visible then you should be good.
 

ScottyT

Regular Member
Joined
Apr 7, 2008
Messages
800
Location
Salt Lake City, Utah, USA
imported post

Did you at least get your money back for the tickets!?!

(I am poor and this is the first thing I think about!)


Also, :lol: at Dave's "A piece of what?"
 

Outsider

Regular Member
Joined
May 22, 2008
Messages
385
Location
Orem, Utah, USA
imported post

Cadet Higham wrote:
Yeah, my brother works there as amanager, and he got my ticket refunded after I called him that night.
Wait, your brother is a manager and you still got asked to leave? Why didn't you have your brother come over?
 

utbagpiper

Banned
Joined
Jul 5, 2006
Messages
4,061
Location
Utah
imported post

Cadet Higham wrote:
Me: "I didn't see any 'No Firearms' signs and neither you or the General Manager previously indicated that this was a problem."

I think you did well with one exception. Please folks do NOT encourage, even tacitly, anyone to be posting signs. They carry no legal weight in Utah anyway other than on private homes and houses of worship.

If a business tells you your gun is not welcome, do not mention signs at all. Ask for a manager. Ask for a refund. Be polite. Don't give anyone any cause to cite disorderly conduct, trespass, disturbing the peace, or otherwise.

Politely tell them you were unaware of their policy, but now that you are aware of it you will certainly be sure to refrain from violating in the future because you will be taking your business elsewhere and encouraging Utah's other gun owners to do likewise.

We are VERY fortunate that signs in most locations do not carry legal weight in Utah. So if we miss one--for whatever reason--we have not actually violated any laws. And if nobody notices, we can keep a gun handy in many places where it would otherwise be illegal if signs and private policies carried legal weight. For those with permits, this is a huge deal. There are times when concealing and having a gun legally at hand is better than having to choose between being unarmed and violation of the law.

Let's not give the business community reason to start demanding such signs. Rather, let's keep them on the defensive by supporting parking lot preemption and other laws.

Again, generally good job.

Charles
 

Outsider

Regular Member
Joined
May 22, 2008
Messages
385
Location
Orem, Utah, USA
imported post

utbagpiper wrote:
Cadet Higham wrote:
Me: "I didn't see any 'No Firearms' signs and neither you or the General Manager previously indicated that this was a problem."

I think you did well with one exception. Please folks do NOT encourage, even tacitly, anyone to be posting signs. They carry no legal weight in Utah anyway other than on private homes and houses of worship.

If a business tells you your gun is not welcome, do not mention signs at all. Ask for a manager. Ask for a refund. Be polite. Don't give anyone any cause to cite disorderly conduct, trespass, disturbing the peace, or otherwise.

Politely tell them you were unaware of their policy, but now that you are aware of it you will certainly be sure to refrain from violating in the future because you will be taking your business elsewhere and encouraging Utah's other gun owners to do likewise.

We are VERY fortunate that signs in most locations do not carry legal weight in Utah. So if we miss one--for whatever reason--we have not actually violated any laws. And if nobody notices, we can keep a gun handy in many places where it would otherwise be illegal if signs and private policies carried legal weight. For those with permits, this is a huge deal. There are times when concealing and having a gun legally at hand is better than having to choose between being unarmed and violation of the law.

Let's not give the business community reason to start demanding such signs. Rather, let's keep them on the defensive by supporting parking lot preemption and other laws.

Again, generally good job.

Charles
Nicely said, Charles. Wow... another Charles... there is two of us! RUN!
 

Cadet Higham

Regular Member
Joined
Oct 25, 2007
Messages
71
Location
Salt Lake, , USA
imported post

As far as the employee/manager handbooks and manuals say Carmike has no policies allowing or not allowing firearms. I didn't want to drag my brother into it and possibly get him into trouble.

Thanks for the reminder about the signs. I won't mention them again.

Still haven't heard anything official back from them.
 

asforme

Campaign Veteran
Joined
Mar 27, 2008
Messages
839
Location
Kalamazoo, MI
imported post

utbagpiper wrote:
Cadet Higham wrote:
Me: "I didn't see any 'No Firearms' signs and neither you or the General Manager previously indicated that this was a problem."

I think you did well with one exception. Please folks do NOT encourage, even tacitly, anyone to be posting signs. They carry no legal weight in Utah anyway other than on private homes and houses of worship.

If a business tells you your gun is not welcome, do not mention signs at all. Ask for a manager. Ask for a refund. Be polite. Don't give anyone any cause to cite disorderly conduct, trespass, disturbing the peace, or otherwise.

Politely tell them you were unaware of their policy, but now that you are aware of it you will certainly be sure to refrain from violating in the future because you will be taking your business elsewhere and encouraging Utah's other gun owners to do likewise.

We are VERY fortunate that signs in most locations do not carry legal weight in Utah. So if we miss one--for whatever reason--we have not actually violated any laws. And if nobody notices, we can keep a gun handy in many places where it would otherwise be illegal if signs and private policies carried legal weight. For those with permits, this is a huge deal. There are times when concealing and having a gun legally at hand is better than having to choose between being unarmed and violation of the law.

Let's not give the business community reason to start demanding such signs. Rather, let's keep them on the defensive by supporting parking lot preemption and other laws.

Again, generally good job.

Charles
I have heard this said many times, and unless I hear a very convincing reason I still disagree. I want every business that does not want me armed to post a sign. I would rather see the sign and take my business elsewhere without having any confrontation or worse, having the cops called. I would then follow up with a letter to the business indicating why I did not patronize them and include a receipt of the business I did patronize.

I don't understand the desire to patronize a business that does not support your rights. I want these businesses to be easy to spot so I can avoid them.
 

xmirage2kx

Regular Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2007
Messages
478
Location
Lehi, Utah, USA
imported post

asforme wrote:
I have heard this said many times, and unless I hear a very convincing reason I still disagree. I want every business that does not want me armed to post a sign. I would rather see the sign and take my business elsewhere without having any confrontation or worse, having the cops called. I would then follow up with a letter to the business indicating why I did not patronize them and include a receipt of the business I did patronize.

I don't understand the desire to patronize a business that does not support your rights. I want these businesses to be easy to spot so I can avoid them.

Easy to spot yes... but it is Easy to see how it has progressed in other states. First the signs are there to warn you not to carry, then soon tresspassing charges start to stick, finally a law is passed that makes the signslegal, and you can lose your permit by going into a store regardless on if you even saw the sign. More and more companies will put up signs if they carry any weight, pretty soon your permit is worthless.

Give an inch on gun rights and you will lose a mile.
 

asforme

Campaign Veteran
Joined
Mar 27, 2008
Messages
839
Location
Kalamazoo, MI
imported post

xmirage2kx wrote:
Give an inch on gun rights and you will lose a mile.
Maybe that's the difference, I don't consider it my right to carry on the property of someone who doesn't want it. I consider it my responsibility to preserve those rights by staying off the property.

Personally I don't disagree with signs carrying legal weight, as long as the law specifies that the sign be very obvious and at every possible entrance.

Yes, it means I may have less places where I can shop and do business, but it will also mean businesses have less customers. I like to let the invisible hand of economics work out these issues. Once businesses start hurting for money, they'll welcome our business. As it is we continue to give money to them while they continue to refuse to support our rights.

What's worse, being forbidden to be in a place where you're not wanted, or continuing to give money to someone who doesn't want you?

I will continue to encourage every business that does not want my firearm there to post the largest most obnoxious victim disarmament zone signs they can buy.
 

xmirage2kx

Regular Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2007
Messages
478
Location
Lehi, Utah, USA
imported post

asforme wrote:
xmirage2kx wrote:
Give an inch on gun rights and you will lose a mile.
Maybe that's the difference, I don't consider it my right to carry on the property of someone who doesn't want it. I consider it my responsibility to preserve those rights by staying off the property.

Personally I don't disagree with signs carrying legal weight, as long as the law specifies that the sign be very obvious and at every possible entrance.

Yes, it means I may have less places where I can shop and do business, but it will also mean businesses have less customers. I like to let the invisible hand of economics work out these issues. Once businesses start hurting for money, they'll welcome our business. As it is we continue to give money to them while they continue to refuse to support our rights.

What's worse, being forbidden to be in a place where you're not wanted, or continuing to give money to someone who doesn't want you?

I will continue to encourage every business that does not want my firearm there to post the largest most obnoxious victim disarmament zone signs they can buy.


Only something like 5% of people in Utah have CHP Permits, so even if every last one of us stoppedshopping inthese places that is a small number. We do not have the pull to make most businesses change.

I think if you open up your private business to the public then it becomes a public place subject to public laws. If you want to make rules like "no guns" or “no red shirts" then adopt a membership based clientele like Costco. But if any old Joe off the street can walk in then any old Joe with a legally carried open gun can walk in.
 

swillden

Regular Member
Joined
Dec 9, 2007
Messages
1,189
Location
Firestone, Colorado
imported post

asforme wrote:
Personally I don't disagree with signs carrying legal weight, as long as the law specifies that the sign be very obvious and at every possible entrance.
Given the choice, do you actually WANT signs to be legally enforceable? If King for a day in a place where signs don't have legal weight, would you pass a law giving it to them?
 
Top