imported post
Wow. Now I know why they turned down the guy in CT for entrance to the police academy for being too smart. How about a logic lesson, then? Whereas P equals a legal act, Q equals an illegal act,X equals police response, X does not necessarily mean P or Q exclusively, and X can equal Q if X follows P, then no conclusion can be logically drawn from X under any circumstance.
You are offering the logical equivelant of:
You are a black freedman. If you go into town you will be lynched by police officers. Therefore, going into town as a black freedman is illegal.
Or perhapsa corollary will help:
You are a police officer. You shake down dealers for drugs, money, and guns. Therefore, shaking down dealers is legal.
How about this. You go into a school zone while off-duty and carrying, and you won't get arrested for violation of the school zone law. Oops. You break the law every time you drive past a school while armed and not on duty, and won't ever get arrested for it. I guess that means that police action has absolutely nothing to do with the legality or illegality of an act.
Can we get a moderator on this clown? :banghead: