imported post
asforme wrote:
That was my understanding. Yes it's illegal for an out-of-stater to carry without a CPL because it is illegal for them to possess without a CPL. But the officer must have reasonable suspicion that the person is a non-resident before they can request ID. And since there is no requirement to carry ID, you cannot be forced to prove your innocence (residency).
Am I correct in this line of thinking?
An officer doesn't have to have any suspicion or justification whatsoever to lawfully request any information or identificationfrom you. The key word is "request". Police are absolutely lawfully entitled to approach you and start talking,ask questions, and ask you to do things. If you comply with the requests,it is a consensual stop and is lawful. Also, if you are driving or crossing an international border you must comply with requests for identification.
That being said, you understand otherwise you have the right to decline to verbally interact with the officer, ask if youare being detained, and ask if you are free to go, correct? Without RS or PC, they cannot lawfully detain orarrest you, or search youunless you give consent.
Remember, you may be arrested and searched anyway. But without RS or PC and without your consent to be searched, an arrest/search is unlawful, any charges would likely be dismissed, and you would probably have the basis for a lawsuit with a nice settlement.