Oh nice. The judge ruled that the Constitution and state law contradict a policy decision so we should go with the policy instead.
Appointed by Jimmah Cahtah in 1979 (why am I NOT surprised).
He received an award because "Judge Marvin H. Shoob of U.S. District Court in Atlanta, a fierce defender of the freedoms guaranteed in the Bill of Rights, will receive the Georgia First Amendment Foundation's annual Charles L. Weltner Freedom of Information Award".
Apparently he doesn't actually defend all of the Bill of Rights, just the ones he likes. His disdain for the 2A is obvious.
A story about what a fierce defender of the BOR he is: