I heard the first few minutes of his show, I usually don't listen, but I made an effort to try today after hearing the question of the day. I had to be away from my computer and a radio so I didn't get to hear all of his show, I probably would have steam coming out of my ears if I heard Nancy's comments being read on the air.
This is HB156 which passed in 2000, and it removed any restriction on carry in a church (except for the obvious stuff written elsewhere like felony)
This lists the acts of 2000, specifically Chapter 455 which is at:
http://www.lrc.state.ky.us/Statrev/ACTS2000/0455.pdf (PDF) go to page six to confirm that the church carry restriction is removed.
Of course all of this tells us what we already know, that there is no law prohibiting the carry of weapons in churches by qualified individuals. You still need to follow the wishes of your religious organization, but the state law prohibiting it simply is not on the books.
That's the only rebuttal that I have. Put simply Nancy needs to provide evidence to support her claim.