There are 2 problems with your advice. The sources are your problem. Mistake 1 : Do not ask LEO's for legal advice they are usually a very poor source and give bias opinions. Mistake 2: dont discuss legal matters with wives of lawyers. If you're serious about really knowing Michgan law's regarding ID's you need to speak to a lawyer directly and not just any lawyer one who specializes in Michgan weapons laws and criminal law. You will get some good advice here. The message boards should give you some ideas but talk to the correct lawyer before you determine what is legal and what is not.