imported post
les_aker wrote:
bohdi wrote:
I have no issues with 1 - 3. They make sense.
I think the part you're missing is that is doesn't matter whether or not it makes sense to you, me, or anyone else. That's the thing about Rights. They are a personal decision that do not require qualification.
Interesting take, not entirely true. If it were so, then we would have had the right to carry in a National Park years ago...We would have a right to carry in all states years ago, and so on.
If you personally want to brush this under the rug by saying it's his right and ignore the larger issue, go ahead.
A man has stated he has a fear of being shot by LEO's. He states he hopes that painting his gun to look the same manner as a toy will prevent that from happening.
There is something very interesting going on in those two sentences that are not exlusive to each other that would make one pause and consider the persons' mental state.
A. Is this fear all the time?
B. Is it only when walking around in public armed?
C. Is it only when walking around in public with a particular piece of armament?
Is it socially and morally irresponsible to not help this man over come his fear?
Is it socially and morally irresponsible to turn a blind eye and encourage this man to continue with his beliefs when it might get him killed?
Scenario A - Fear all the time
Like most phobias, if it was severe and debilitating, the man would most likely not leave his house
Scenario B - While armed in public
Logic would say that you then avoid doing things that you are afraid of. If we encourage someone to do something they are afraid of doing, they are more likely to react in a way that could get them killed. --- I'm afraid of getting shot by LEO's, I'll carry a gun --- So what is the likelihood the guy in fear now shoots first unprovoked at a LEO as a result of this unnatural fear of LEOs?
Scenario C - While carrying a particular weapon
Logic would say that if you have a no fear of going about carrying a 1911, but do have a fear carrying a Glock20, you should not carry a Glock 20. Carrying a Glock colored Pink or carrying a Glock colored black is not going to change the fact you are still carrying a Glock nor will the color eliminate your fear.
Next one has to consider why a LEO would shoot a citizen.
1> The LEO is mentally incompetent/insane/snapped
2> It was an accident/squeezed trigger and didn't mean to/improper procedure/etc etc
3> They were baited into doing so
4> Fear for their life or that of others
5> They are an evil mother that slipped into LE under the radar and now have the opportunity and means to kill innocent people at will and until stopped
Only 1 and 5 explain unprovoked shooting of citizens and can provide support for the phobia. Nothing can prevent 1 and 5 from occuring. 2 - 4 require an initiating action from the citizen.