imported post
ItTakesAWolf wrote:
"what he deems necessary for his own personal protection"
ya, if he lives in Mogadishu.
carrying a handgun cc or oc is in the sake of self defense...that, is an attention stunt....
That PLR would be just as effective as whatever choice of sidearm you carry as well, in Mogadishu. Which is to say probably not "very".
What is the insinuation there? Are you implying a semi-automatic .223 (Not 5.56) pistol, with a short length barrel and very short gas system (lower muzzle energy/velocity), is somehow "vastly more dangerous" than a common sidearm?
Have you considered even the remote possibility that there are
many people who feel that it is simply the best choice of defense for themselves, especially being prior service and having an extreme familiarity with the maintenance, upkeep, and feel of the firearm?
I am curious what rational, well thought out, articulated point could genuinely be made in support of the idea that the PLR is a poor firearm for personal protection?
Not appearance based hype, but rational argument against using a PLR as a primary defense firearm.
Out of curiosity, would you likewise state someone was showboating for carrying:
--Ruger Super Redhawk
--S&W Magnum .500
--Taurus Raging Bull
--Desert Eagle
--S&W N or X frames
...and well, I could keep this list up for far longer than I will. I think you get the point.
If it's a magazine capacity issue, would limiting it to 10 rounds work for you? If so I know of a great organization you could join.
There is definitely a public perception issue with pistol image, and the founders of this site are adamant about trying to coddle it. Not that I disagree that on a national level their positioning has anti-dramatic merit, but if the occasional individual feels the need to carry one, it doesn't necessarily mean he is being a showboat, nor is he intending to cause any sort of issue.
He is simply a citizen exercising his rights to carry, and frankly, if you had more people walking around with PLR's, I honestly don't think anybody would give two monkey turds.
In fact, "if" a hypothetical shootout would occur, you would realize real quick that in urban environments, the larger .38, .45acp, or even 9mm would be a better suited round than that PLR having such a short gas system, for energy transfer at close targets.