imported post
Dave Workman wrote:
Ladies and Gentlemen:
I have a note from one of my Examiner.com readers, obviously a WA resident, who offers a very well-thought-out, sincere comment, and now is your opportunity to either shine like a star, or stink like an ogre, with a well-thought-out reply, or something less.
How you reply will speak volumes more about you than about Ruby.
Ruby says:
Thanks,Dave, for getting back to me. As I said, I am opposed to open carry. I am a gun owner and I respect other people's opinions and practices. I am opposed to it because it is not customary in our society at the present time, and it does scare some people. And it is not without some limitations, as you described in your book Washington State Gun Rights and Responsibilities. We will not convert people who are on the fence about gun rights by scaring them. The other reason is that I do not want everyone to know that I have a firearm. Some criminal may just decide that he will try to take it away from me. I also think that for some gun owners, not all, but some, it's an ego trip. Look at me, I have a gun. I would be interested in hearing what the rest of you think about it and if you have carried openly, what your experience with it has been.
May 3, 7:45 PM
Dear Ms. Ruby,
You raise some common objections to O.C. They are, however,fairly easily answered.
1. "I am opposed to it because it is not customary in our society at the present time, and it does scare some people."
At one time it was not customary for blacks and whites to eat in the same room, drink from the same fountain, go to the same schools or date/marry each other. How did that change? For one, by doing it, in public, in plainview, and demonstrating that the sky would not fall. (It also took some blood-shed and legislative action, sometimes backed up by force of arms. I think we can do this a lot safer and more peacefully via both quiet personal and organisedpublic demonstration and, where required, court actions and legislation.)
If Civil Rights "scare some people", again, demonstration and education will dispel this misconstruction. In any event, Civil Rights should in no way be dependent on if they "scare" anyone.
2. "Some criminal may just decide that he will try to take it away from me."
In theory, a reasonable hypothesis, but in reality, not supported by evidence. I don't think you can find a statistically significant number of such cases, if you can find any at all. If criminals are trying to do this, they are having a notable lack of success. It may actually be that the reverse is true, as there are a number of reports of Citizens disarming criminals and using the firearm to legally repel/detain their attacker, and a few documented cases of O.C. detering criminals without the weapon being drawn, sometimes without the bearer even being aware of the situation.
3. "I also think that for some gun owners, not all, but some, it's an ego trip. Look at me, I have a gun."
This is true in any human endeavor, but again is not a valid reason to ban the practice or restrict a Civil Right. Else we would have to restrict vehicles of all types, professional atheletes, politicians, college students, artists and actors... well, I'm sure you get the point.
4. My experiencein O.C. here inArizona (and in Utah, Vermont and New Hampshire) has been completely positive or neutral, with only one exception thus far. IHOP apparently has a No Firearms policy, and I was unable to eat there after being a Designated Driver one night. SoI took my business to an establishment that did not discriminate. But ironically, amid all the calls of scaring the public, a majority ofpeople do not even notice. A minority do, and a few people either express approval or ask questions, allowing me to help educate them onthe laws and responsibilities inherent to thiscustom.
I hope this response is helpful.Do please remember that, as advocates of the Second Amendment, weare on the same side,albeit using differing tactics and strategies againsta common opponent. Travel in peace and carry safely, whatever method you prefer.
Edit/Added: Ruby, I posted this after only reading page one. Looks like most of this already got covered. Silly me, read the entire thread next time... Also, I made an assumption about your gender, then saw you had registered and posted. Your profile does not specify. If I am in error, please accept my apology. Lastly, welcome, and I am glad you had a good time at the meet'n'great. The Washingtonbunch has always sounded like a very hospitable group of people. Hope youstay and add to the liveliness of the place.