Recoil88
Regular Member
imported post
What kind of ammunition do you use for personal defense rounds? I use hydra shocksin my m&p 40c.
What kind of ammunition do you use for personal defense rounds? I use hydra shocksin my m&p 40c.
Ah, I see. I've never really heard of that. Fairly certain that you'd be ok. I'll see if there's any truth to this myth...Well it would figure that FMJ's would penetrate more.....no?.....in the cooler months people (yes, criminals are people ) would be wearing more/thicker clothing....or would a hollowpoint penetrate just as well?.....
http://www.theboxotruth.com/American Boy With a Gun wrote:Ah, I see. I've never really heard of that. Fairly certain that you'd be ok. I'll see if there's any truth to this myth...Well it would figure that FMJ's would penetrate more.....no?.....in the cooler months people (yes, criminals are people ) would be wearing more/thicker clothing....or would a hollowpoint penetrate just as well?.....
You need to remember that over-penetration can be a worse problem... if you get a pass through what is behind your intended target?Well i just sorta figured.....and with some of what zig and Stainless said in Zig's thread, and i wouldnt mind having more than one type of ammunition available to me....but yes, some of the info im reading on hollowpoints make strong mention of good winter clothing penetration....i might just stick with one....or maybe ill switch it up depending on how i feel that morning.....idk
I plan to start loading my own for my CZ as the current 9X18 loads are so anemic and the CZ was built for far hotter loads than the Makorov.I now carry hand loaded Hornady JHPs.
American Boy With a Gun wrote:You need to remember that over-penetration can be a worse problem... if you get a pass through what is behind your intended target?Well i just sorta figured.....and with some of what zig and Stainless said in Zig's thread, and i wouldnt mind having more than one type of ammunition available to me....but yes, some of the info im reading on hollowpoints make strong mention of good winter clothing penetration....i might just stick with one....or maybe ill switch it up depending on how i feel that morning.....idk
The flaw in your thinking is this...(highly trained police officers) I have seen more officers shoot than I care to and I don't want any but a select few backing me up!IMHO this is another one of those issues (like 9mm vs. 40S&W) that gets a lot of "air time" but is really marginally important.
Think about it ... approximately 90% of self defense situations will end when you draw your pistol. Doesn't matter what kind of pistol ... when most perps see a gun they turn and run in the opposite direction (in search of easier prey).
Of the remaining 10% ... probably 5-7% will end when you pull the trigger ... whether you hit the guy or not. The muzzle blast, and/or feeling of a round impacting anywhere on the body, will cause the bad guy to turn and flee (or fall to the ground blubbering and crying - happens a lot).
Which leaves us with 3-5% of incidents ... those hard core offenders who really have to be "put down" to end the attack (often drunk or high on something).
Here's the bad news for these guys ... they're going to take multiple hits to stop AND they're likely going to get to you (and do some damage) before they go down. Unless you score a head shot ... break a major leg bone, or shred the heart, or a huge artery (think aorta) these guys will keep coming even with 5+ rounds of 9mm, .40, .45 ... .357 ... just about any of the major defensive calibers in them. The literature is FULL of these scenarios.
And here's more bad news ... to get those 5+ hits ... you're likely going to fire 10, 15, 20+ rounds. Even experienced, well trained police officers miss MOST of the shots they fire in these kinds of scenarios (they score hits 10-20% of the time!)
So is overpenetration with ball ammo and wound cavity caused by expansion a consideration? I suppose so ... but the rounds you'll REALLY need to be concerned about aren't the overpenetrating ones (which will only have marginal velocity left once they exit anyway) ... but all the misses. And is a round that expands better than one that doesn't? I guess ... but when you need to score 5+ shots to get a stop it probably isn't going to matter if it's 5+ hits with FMJ ammo or HP ammo.
So bottom line? My "ammo selection philosophy" ... especially with automatics (less important with revolvers) is this: use the most reliable brand of ammo you can ... the one that feeds through your automatic FLAWLESSLY.
Difference in stopping power between FMJ and a "fancy HP"? Trivial.
Difference between a round that goes "BANG!" and one that jams your pistol? Potentially fatal.
autosurgeon wrote:American Boy With a Gun wrote:You need to remember that over-penetration can be a worse problem... if you get a pass through what is behind your intended target?Well i just sorta figured.....and with some of what zig and Stainless said in Zig's thread, and i wouldnt mind having more than one type of ammunition available to me....but yes, some of the info im reading on hollowpoints make strong mention of good winter clothing penetration....i might just stick with one....or maybe ill switch it up depending on how i feel that morning.....idk
The flaw in your thinking is this...(highly trained police officers) I have seen more officers shoot than I care to and I don't want any but a select few backing me up!
Most of em can hardly hit the broad side of a barn from inside and that is at a range with no stress!
This is the fundamental reason why many people, including me, are very skeptical of the modern technique for use by the average gun carrier.And here's more bad news ... to get those 5+ hits ... you're likely going to fire 10, 15, 20+ rounds. Even experienced, well trained police officers miss MOST of the shots they fire in these kinds of scenarios (they score hits 10-20% of the time!)
Well here is another point for ya...
JHP tend to lose more energy when going through obstructions therefore not being as apt to kill someone downrange...
However my final point is that a good JHP or EFMJ that works correctly is far more likely to get you a stop if you get those direct hits then a round that does not expand...
And here is why... An expanded round is more likely to deviate from the path of entry therefor doing more damage than a round that goes straight through. Anyone that hunts knows that a SP or HP does more damage and is far more likely to produce a clean kill.
Now some people don't like to think about clean kills in relation to SD. However once I deploy my firearm I want the threat stopped therefore I train for double taps on 6 inch steel plates while moving.. I also use USPSA targets and work from behind cover around obstructions and from the ground. I run until my heart rate is up and then shoot. All of these things are easy to do and produce a far better chance that if my time comes I will be ready to deal with it.
We are told not to (shoot to kill but rather shoot to stop) I agree with the nomenclature... but if a stop means the perp is dead so be it... I am not going to shoot once and see if the perp is done ...no I am going to dump at least 4 center of mass while changing position to make myself less of a target. Then if the perp is still a threat 4 more and so on.
No handgun bullet is the magic answer but I prefer one that will do the most damage in the calibers I choose to carry.