Comfort is important... couldn't agree more!
For your larger pieces you might find better support and more stability with a leather holster on a reinforced leather belt... just a suggestion if you ever decide you want to carry one of the larger cannons again.
It surprised me, the difference a really good belt can make. I wear my Galco 1.5" belt no matter what holster I choose for the day. Even with a paddle the extra stability is remarkable.