I'd be afraid of over penetration from that kind of gun. I couldn't care less if you carried a .50 Barrett on your back but if you had to use it in a self defense situation knowing your target and what's behind it would be all important.
Isn't that always important? ;-) A near miss on a .22lr could be subjected to the same argument as overpenetration.
I find the gun to be far more accurate than the short barrel and short sight radius of 'conventional' hanguns. Also, the positions of the hands; not in the same spot, contributes to more accuracy and a steadier hand. I was also, at first, saying to myself "this is ridiculous, but fun!" But it's really grown on me. I'm seeing all the positives instead of all the excuses and rhetoric against it.
Just like OC.
I have a more granular control over what I aim at. In a panic situation, you're only half as good as you are at the range. I can pick an eyeball at 50 yards with this sucker! Can you do that with ANY conventional handgun?
Who cares? If your target is 50yds away, how can they be a real threat to you?
Defense of others, forcible felonies, etc...
As I just said, in a real-world situation, adrenaline, etc... I won't be that good. My odds of missing with this thing are virtually nil. Your 'normal' handgun? Good luck!
If I am clear beyond the target, let er rip. Not clear? Still have to take the shot to save the good guy (be it me or someone else)? Sternum, or any hard bone. I can make tight shots like that with this gun. "Normal" handguns just can't give you that.
Some people choose not to care.
What if the bad guy takes a hostage? Can you make that shot with your 3 inch barrel and equivalent sight radius?
What if he finds or makes cover? Can your .380 beat that door panel and still be effective?
Having a Right is not the same as having the ABILITY. With my AMD-65, I get to set the stage, not the bad guy.
Besides, your gun might say "Not a victim," Mine says "Are you effing kidding me? Not in a bajillion years should you even be having that thought!"
Will it be more attention-getting? Probably; but I'm not painting any part of it orange, and I'm building a retention holster with proper trigger cover for it. I'm not going for theatrics or challenges. It's my new favorite gun, I'm more comfortable with it, it extends my options and abilities by several orders of magnitude.... It's just good all around.
I also don't have to learn two sets of shooting skills. 1-point sling, and the stance and hold is very much like a rifle; which I'm already really damn good with. I'm not really a handgun guy to begin with, so this extends my extensive rifle skills as well.
It's just a damn good choice
FOR ME no matter how I look at it.