karagog
New member
I just signed up on opencarry.org so I could share my experience open-carrying in Ann Arbor. This post also contains a correspondence with U of M's police department regarding carrying on their campus.
I just bought a Glock 9mm a few weeks ago, and also applied for my CPL. Taking the home protection class required for the CPL taught me a lot about the law and gave me a great opportunity to ask questions about open-carry. The instructors seemed to discourage it, but had to admit that it was our right to do so if we wanted. I have decided that even after I get my CPL I still want to open-carry around town because I have nothing to hide and I think someone needs to start doing it to show the public that not everyone who has a gun is evil. So now every day when I walk my dog downtown I carry my glock on my hip with a full magazine 15+1 in the chamber, and a spare mag with 15 rounds in a slot on my holster.
This has nothing to do with paranoia or machismo, which accusations some people in my family have thrown at me, this is all about 2nd amendment rights and demonstrating to the public that guns can be handled safely and responsibly. I can say that after 5 walks downtown I have had nothing but positive reactions from people. In fact, nobody has even mentioned my gun, they are more interested in petting my cute little long-haired miniature dachshund. I have stopped to talk with little old ladies, none of which were intimidated or even seemed to notice that I was carrying. I even got the impression that some of them felt very safe around me, like if something went down I would be one to protect them. Of course I did have one (possibly) negative reaction, where a family of 3 walking on the sidewalk towards me completely avoided eye contact and stepped off the sidewalk by at least 3 feet yielding the entire path to me and my dog. It even seemed like the father was trying to shield his daughter (possibly 5 years old) from "the bad man with a pistol". All I was doing was walking my dog, smiling and saying hello...I guess I can't satisfy everyone.
I have seen some posts in the forums saying "stay away from Ann Arbor", even some where opencarry.org members are afraid to drive through ann arbor on I-94 because of their "strict" gun control. I contacted U of M's police department to ask them what the real policy was before actually going downtown with my gun. Here is a transcript of my e-mails (so far):
I am still awaiting the response to my last e-mail, and I'll be sure to post it when I get it. It turns out (based on my recent experience) that Ann Arbor is not overrun with liberal pansies who freak out at the sight of a gun (though I have seen one or two). I would consider myself a liberal, but I am all for the second amendment, and I have met many people who share a similar belief system. I carry my gun everywhere I'm able to without a CPL: Grocery shopping, walking my dog around town, restaurants (and once I get the CPL I will open-carry practically everywhere, including any pistol free zone except U of M's property), and like to consider myself an activist, raising awareness about the right to self defense and desensitizing people who irrationally fear guns and gun-owners. My hope is that soon pistols in the open will be a common sight around Ann Arbor (much like the wild west, which is not too far from reality with reductions in public safety budgets).
So those of you who are afraid to carry your pistols openly in Ann Arbor, it's not that bad! I-94 (or any public street not owned or controlled by U of M) is still open for car-carry if you have a CPL, according to my still-unfolding correspondence with U of M police. So far I have only been as close as Main St, but on each walk I get one block closer, always being cognizant of what buildings are around me and if they belong to the U of M.
Disclaimer: Don't use me or this post as an excuse if you get in trouble with the police. Do your own research (like I am) and find out for yourself what is legal and not legal. I would suggest taking a CPL course, even if you don't intend to get a CPL. It will drastically change your perspective on handguns!
I just bought a Glock 9mm a few weeks ago, and also applied for my CPL. Taking the home protection class required for the CPL taught me a lot about the law and gave me a great opportunity to ask questions about open-carry. The instructors seemed to discourage it, but had to admit that it was our right to do so if we wanted. I have decided that even after I get my CPL I still want to open-carry around town because I have nothing to hide and I think someone needs to start doing it to show the public that not everyone who has a gun is evil. So now every day when I walk my dog downtown I carry my glock on my hip with a full magazine 15+1 in the chamber, and a spare mag with 15 rounds in a slot on my holster.
This has nothing to do with paranoia or machismo, which accusations some people in my family have thrown at me, this is all about 2nd amendment rights and demonstrating to the public that guns can be handled safely and responsibly. I can say that after 5 walks downtown I have had nothing but positive reactions from people. In fact, nobody has even mentioned my gun, they are more interested in petting my cute little long-haired miniature dachshund. I have stopped to talk with little old ladies, none of which were intimidated or even seemed to notice that I was carrying. I even got the impression that some of them felt very safe around me, like if something went down I would be one to protect them. Of course I did have one (possibly) negative reaction, where a family of 3 walking on the sidewalk towards me completely avoided eye contact and stepped off the sidewalk by at least 3 feet yielding the entire path to me and my dog. It even seemed like the father was trying to shield his daughter (possibly 5 years old) from "the bad man with a pistol". All I was doing was walking my dog, smiling and saying hello...I guess I can't satisfy everyone.
I have seen some posts in the forums saying "stay away from Ann Arbor", even some where opencarry.org members are afraid to drive through ann arbor on I-94 because of their "strict" gun control. I contacted U of M's police department to ask them what the real policy was before actually going downtown with my gun. Here is a transcript of my e-mails (so far):
Hello,
I'm in the process of getting my CPL from the state of Michigan, and I'm wondering if U of M campus has a gun law that is separate from the state's. The state law says that a CPL holder cannot carry concealed on a school property, but after researching more I learned that a CPL holder can carry an exposed pistol in any pistol-free zone, including a school. I also know about preemption, which says that local ordinance cannot override state law, so my initial assumption is that I can open-carry on campus once I get my CPL. Please tell me if I'm wrong, and if so, can you tell me where central campus begins on all sides so I don't get arrested? In other words, which streets should I avoid when open-carrying with my CPL (I'm always talking about walking around while carrying, because I'm aware if I was driving it would always be considered concealed-carry, and is therefore off-limits because it's a pistol-free zone).
Thanks!
<my name>
---- Response from UMPD ----
Mr. <my last name> –
Like all universities in the state of Michigan, the governing boards (in our case the Board of Regents) have made the campuses “weapons free zones.” At the U-M, in addition to state and federal laws, the Regents’ Ordinance (titled An Ordinance to Regulate Parking and Traffic and to Regulate the Use and Protection of the Buildings and Property of the Regents of the University of Michigan) is enforced on U-M owned, managed or leased property. The Ordinance can be found online at http://regents.umich.edu/ordinance.pdf
I’ve copied and pasted here the pertinent portion of the Ordinance that prohibits weapons on campus.
Article X: Weapons
Section 1. Scope of Article X
Article X applies to all property owned, leased or otherwise controlled by the
Regents of the University of MIchigan and applies regardless of whether the
Individual has a concealed weapons permit or is otherwise authorized by law to
possess, discharge, or use any device referenced below.
Section 2. Possession of Firearms, Dangerous Weapons and Knives
Except as otherwise provided in Section 4, no person shall, while on any property
owned, leased, or otherwise controlled by the Regents of the University of
Michigan:
(1) possess any firearm or any other dangerous weapon as defined in or
interpreted under Michigan law or
(2) wear on his or her person or carry in his or her clothing any knife, sword or
machete having a blade longer than four (4) inches, or, in the case of a knife
with a mechanism to lock the blade in place when open, longer than three
(3) inches.
The Michigan State Police also have issued guidance that states that individuals can’t carry in locations in which it violates local ordinance.
Here is a link to a website that includes maps of the various campuses of U-M Ann Arbor including the map for Central Campus. http://www.umich.edu/~info/mapsAndDirections.html#anchor_centralCampus
---- My response ----
Thank you for the information, I am trying to stay within the law and exercise my 2nd amendment rights and you are helping me tremendously. I do have some follow-up questions about your response.
You said that the Michigan State Police (hereafter MSP) have issued "guidance" that states we cannot violate local ordinance by carrying a weapon, but I interpret that as a suggestion and not a law. Suggestions don't preempt my constitutional right to carry. Is that a correct interpretation?
So if I follow the ordinance (even though it seems the law does not force me to do so), and I understand you correctly, I can use that campus map as a guide for which places are off-limits to me while I open-carry, by looking at which buildings belong to U of M. As long as I avoid those buildings I am satisfying the ordinance. What about sidewalks adjacent to those buildings, do those belong to the university or are those public domain? In other words, can I still carry on campus as long as I stick to the sidewalks on the main roads, which (I think) are owned and maintained by the state of Michigan?
And here is a philosophical question for you: How does banning guns on campus improve safety? I have been threatened before while on campus and didn't have any means to protect myself because I'm a law-abiding citizen. It seems the ordinance to ban firearms actually helps law-breaking citizens because they know that nobody can defend themselves if they want to take advantage of the unarmed populace. I don't really need a response to this question, I just pose it rhetorically because the ordinance doesn't make any sense to me. I hope we can repeal that soon.
Thanks,
<my first name>
I am still awaiting the response to my last e-mail, and I'll be sure to post it when I get it. It turns out (based on my recent experience) that Ann Arbor is not overrun with liberal pansies who freak out at the sight of a gun (though I have seen one or two). I would consider myself a liberal, but I am all for the second amendment, and I have met many people who share a similar belief system. I carry my gun everywhere I'm able to without a CPL: Grocery shopping, walking my dog around town, restaurants (and once I get the CPL I will open-carry practically everywhere, including any pistol free zone except U of M's property), and like to consider myself an activist, raising awareness about the right to self defense and desensitizing people who irrationally fear guns and gun-owners. My hope is that soon pistols in the open will be a common sight around Ann Arbor (much like the wild west, which is not too far from reality with reductions in public safety budgets).
So those of you who are afraid to carry your pistols openly in Ann Arbor, it's not that bad! I-94 (or any public street not owned or controlled by U of M) is still open for car-carry if you have a CPL, according to my still-unfolding correspondence with U of M police. So far I have only been as close as Main St, but on each walk I get one block closer, always being cognizant of what buildings are around me and if they belong to the U of M.
Disclaimer: Don't use me or this post as an excuse if you get in trouble with the police. Do your own research (like I am) and find out for yourself what is legal and not legal. I would suggest taking a CPL course, even if you don't intend to get a CPL. It will drastically change your perspective on handguns!