Just something to mull around....
Police have only one reason for requesting your ID...
It's the first step of building a prosecution against you. The first step in finding reason, with little effort, of removing your freedom or your money. A no-risk fishing expedition. I feel no obligation, morally or legally, in assisting in that effort. None.
A more candid view point......
Rolling over on your back like a cowed dog is not improving the "PR" of open carry in the eyes of the cop intent on manipulating you into forfeiting our rights. It reinforces the behavior that needs to be changed.
I have trained horses and dogs most of my life. It's frustrating when someone enters the picture and un-does all the efforts put into correcting a behavior problem. Firm, consistent discipline is required to break a dog of jumping on people, for example. It can change having an animal you resent and distrust into having a useful trusted companion. It all hinges on the discipline you apply, and when. I don't tolerate a dog jumping on me. One of the main reasons why dogs will jump up on people is a way of dominating. They want to show that they are the tough one and by acting aggressive and even plaRyful they can achieve what they want, which is dominance. When a dog jumps on a human of its own free will, it is not "greeting" the human, it is asserting its dominance over the human; it is the dog communicating that it is alpha and/or wishes to own/control the human. A subordinate would never dream of running over and jumping on the alpha dog of the pack. Space is respect and lower members of the pack respect the higher members. If your dog jumps on humans, it does not respect them. Dogs like and need consistency, so if you are not allowing your dog to jump on you, everyone in the family and everyone who greets the dog must do the same. It will only confuse a dog if you allow them to jump on some people who say they do not mind, and tell him not to jump on others. Having a confused, aggressive dog around is not safe or comforting. While the dog is viewed as the problem, the truth is the responsibility lies on who allowed the behavior to build to the point it becomes a problem.
No small amount of effort, trial, error, disappointment and triumph goes into training a dog. I hope you don't find it unreasonable if I ask that you don't undo all that by using the same firm and consistent discipline we use.
At least consider this: You're setting someone else up to be jumped on by ignoring this basic handling information. Nobody deserves that, and you're instilling confusion in the beast that will require some harsh discipline to correct.