trevorthebusdriver
Regular Member
Does WA have any specific "Castle Doctrine" or "Stand Your Ground" laws, or just RCW 9A.16.050(Justifiable Homicide)?
Thanks, Big Dave! Interesting that it would be in Jury Instructions, but not in RCW.
Does WA have any specific "Castle Doctrine" or "Stand Your Ground" laws, or just RCW 9A.16.050(Justifiable Homicide)?
Welcome, in Washington State stand your ground is based in case law and many feel this is much stronger as it has been through the Washington State Courts, cited cases listed in the notes.
Note that even though our state supports the stand your ground it must be necessary and reasonable.
I do think that "necessary and reasonable" is bull scat,,, that you just made up....
The whole point of "stand your ground" is that "you" do NOT,,, have to find a place to run away to, or from, a threat....
Washington state has , both Castle doctrin, and Stand you ground, either through RCW or case law,,, and they both work great!!!
I do think that "necessary and reasonable" is bull scat,,, that you just made up....
The whole point of "stand your ground" is that "you" do NOT,,, have to find a place to run away to, or from, a threat....
Washington state has , both Castle doctrine, and Stand you ground, either through RCW or case law,,, and they both work great!!!
Bull Scat, lol with out it being necessary and reasonable then anyone could go about shooting anyone who might have looked at them in a different way, said the wrong thing, bumped into them while waiting in line.
Does this concept really shake you to the core?
Don't you think someone needs cause before possibly taking a life?
You think I made up the definition or how it applies to entire chapter in RCW 9A.16, Necessary and Reasonable, :lol: take a look at RCW 9A.16.010 Definitions and are requirements, exactly what are you afraid of an epiphany?
The definition of Necessary in 9A.10.010 does not require anyone to try and run away or hide but is a requirement of a lesser force, if reasonable to defend yourself or another against an unlawful force.
As seen recently in Chehalis where a home owner defended himself in their home versus in Vancouver, WA where a man shot another during car prowl, fight and then according to the news the car prowler was walking away and shot 4 times in the chest, many will not see that as being reasonable as the imminent threat had dissipated.
I do think that "necessary and reasonable" is bull scat,,, that you just made up....
The whole point of "stand your ground" is that "you" do NOT,,, have to find a place to run away to, or from, a threat....
Washington state has , both Castle doctrin [sic], and Stand you ground, either through RCW or case law,,, and they both work great!!!
the car prowler was walking away and shot 4 times in the chest!!!W T F dosen't sound like he was walking away to me if he was shot in the chest.
Bull Scat, lol with out it being necessary and reasonable then anyone could go about shooting anyone who might have looked at them in a different way, said the wrong thing, bumped into them while waiting in line.
Does this concept really shake you to the core?
Don't you think someone needs cause before possibly taking a life?
You think I made up the definition or how it applies to entire chapter in RCW 9A.16, Necessary and Reasonable, :lol: take a look at RCW 9A.16.010 Definitions and are requirements, exactly what are you afraid of an epiphany?
The definition of Necessary in 9A.10.010 does not require anyone to try and run away or hide but is a requirement of a lesser force, if reasonable to defend yourself or another against an unlawful force.
As seen recently in Chehalis where a home owner defended himself in their home versus in Vancouver, WA where a man shot another during car prowl, fight and then according to the news the car prowler was walking away and shot 4 times in the chest, many will not see that as being reasonable as the imminent threat had dissipated.
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, are irritating. Please learn the use of PERIODS (these things ..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................)
I do think that "necessary and reasonable" is bull scat,,, that you just made up....
The whole point of "stand your ground" is that "you" do NOT,,, have to find a place to run away to, or from, a threat....
Washington state has , both Castle doctrin, and Stand you ground, either through RCW or case law,,, and they both work great!!!
Seriously,, bigdave??
did my post about SYG, imply that I, you, or anyone could, should or would use deadly force under those circumstances???
Sooo,,, A lawyer, that I met, in Olympia, on feb 8, during a 2A rally, and I was impressed with...
Has Nothng to write about my post about SYG...
He doesnt even respond to bigdaves rediculas reply...
He just wants to complain about my excessive use of ........... and ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
I write like I talk...
When I tell you something,,, you will know when my sentence ends,,, and when I am making a point!!!
When I need to call a Good lawyer,, especially if it is a Stand your ground case,,,
I will NOT be calling YOU,,,
my wallet is thinner now, I just took out your card,,, tore it in half,, and threw it in the trash..............
Well, when you need a lawyer (especially if it is a "stand your ground" case), please feel free to call me anyway and I will gladly refer you to several superb attorneys who can provide you excellent representation.When I need to call a Good lawyer,, especially if it is a Stand your ground case,,,
I will NOT be calling YOU,,,
my wallet is thinner now, I just took out your card,,, tore it in half,, and threw it in the trash..............
Well, when you need a lawyer (especially if it is a "stand your ground" case), please feel free to call me anyway and I will gladly refer you to several superb attorneys who can provide you excellent representation.
I get mad sometimes because folks get off on the wrong things, they waste the band width.