imported post
I liked the legal aid society suggestion. No idea if it would pan out, though.
Realize, too, that by you getting a lawyer, they may decide to settle. A lawyer on your side will be able to correctly evaluate whether their "evidence" would stand up to scrutiny in court. For example, the forum postings should still be on-line. A judge or jury can evaluate it for themselves. An attorney on your side will know how the "evidence" will play in court. And State Farm's attorney will know. Thus, the SF attorney will know that your atty actually knows. Suddenly, the playing field will be much closer to level.
Maybe SF will still try to limit their payout to less than obligated, but they will suddenly dropany nonsense "evidence", because their attorney will realize your attorney is no dummy and can correctly evaluate the situation.
Don't overlook the fact that the criminal accusations are maybe just bluff to put you off, with no real intention of actually trying use the evidence. One thing that makes me think this is that you have not, in all the time that has passed, been indicted for insurance fraud. If they really thought you were a crook, truly thought it, and if theirevidence is so good, why didn't they refer it to a prosecutor for a grand jury? You see how this tends to show that even they don't believe you're a fraud, and tends to show that they know their evidence won't hold up in court?
It may also be that they don't really know for sure. But, figure if they raise the specter of fraud, if you are actually guilty, you will be scared off your claim.
For the forum in general: Anybody have any idea how it would play for an "insured" to fire back something like: "OK. Lets see how this goes. I'm going to the State Insurance Commission. Lets see how your self-described "evidence" holds water with them. You can pay me, try your luck in criminal court by prosecuting me, or put up with a regulatory investigation that must cost $10K. Its your call. I'm not a fraud. I know it.And, you know it. I'm calling your bluff."