imported post
TFred wrote:
Ok, I'll ask...
Is this a good thing or a bad thing?
Does this mean that the rest of the judges on the circuit thought that the decision was bad? Or perhaps that the rest of the judges on the circuit saw a chance to get their names on a landmark decision that will affect the country for generations to come?
TFred
Could have many different outcomes.
1. Could be overturned. This would eliminate the Circuit "split" on incorporation and SCOTUS might decide not to take any of the 2A incorporation cases.
2. It gets reaffirmed. No real change from a few days ago.
3. It get reaffirmed and the full 9th rules to allow gunshows at theCounty Fairgrounds and thus eliminates them as"sensitive places" .
The initial effect is that the 3 panel judge ruling is put on hold, and therefore the 2nd Amendment is back to being "not incorporated" in the 9th Circuit Court jurisdiction.